Sector I (Systems 1–9): Competency, Personal Knowledge & Verdict Inquiry
FRE 601: Broad presumption of competency; state law (e.g., Dead Man's Statutes) governs civil claims/defenses where state law supplies the rule of decision.
FRE 602: Sufficient evidence to support a finding of firsthand sensory perception (hearing a statement gives personal knowledge it was said, not that it is true).
FRE 603–605: Secular affirmation suffices; interpreters must be qualified and sworn; presiding judge is strictly barred from testifying (no objection required to preserve).
FRE 606 & Peña-Rodriguez: Jurors cannot testify before co-jurors (Rule 606(a) requires opportunity to object outside jury's presence). Post-verdict inquiry bars internal deliberations/mental processes/intoxication, allowing only: (1) extraneous prejudicial information, (2) outside influence, (3) clerical verdict-form entry mistake, or (4) clear racial animus as a significant motivating factor in a criminal conviction.
Sector II (Systems 10–18): Examination, Sequestration & Memory
FRE 611 & 614: Mode/order control; leading questions barred on direct (except preliminary matters, young/forgetful witnesses, or hostile/adverse witnesses) and permitted on cross. Scope of cross = subject matter of direct + credibility. Objections to judge questioning (Rule 614) preserved at next opportunity when jury is absent.
FRE 615 (2023 Amendment): Mandatory courtroom exclusion on request except for (1) natural person party, (2) one designated officer/employee of an entity party, (3) essential person (e.g., needed expert), or (4) statutory exemption. Rule 615(a) only excludes from the courtroom; Rule 615(b) requires a separate order to bar out-of-court transcript access/disclosure.
FRE 612 vs. FRE 803(5): Refreshing recollection uses any stimulus so witness testifies from revived memory (adverse party gets automatic rights if used while testifying; discretionary "justice requires" if used before). Recorded Recollection (803(5)) requires fresh making/adoption + accuracy foundation; read into evidence, but received as an exhibit only if offered by an adverse party.
Sector III (Systems 19–27): Impeachment, Bias & Rule 801(d)(1)(A)
FRE 607: Any party may impeach (even calling party), but cannot call a witness solely as a subterfuge/pretext to introduce inadmissible hearsay.
Bias & Contradiction: Bias (financial bonus, pending charges, plea expectation) is never collateral—extrinsic evidence is permitted and protected by Confrontation rights. Extrinsic proof of contradiction is barred on purely collateral matters.
FRE 613(a)–(b) (Dec 2024 Sequence): Need not show prior statement to witness first, but must show opposing counsel on request. Under amended Rule 613(b), extrinsic evidence of a prior inconsistent statement is inadmissible until after the witness has an opportunity to explain/deny and the adverse party can examine (unless court orders otherwise; inapplicable to Rule 801(d)(2) party admissions).
Rule 801(d)(1)(A) Nov vs. Dec 2026: Under the Nov 11, 2026 baseline, substantive use requires prior statement under penalty of perjury at a trial, hearing, proceeding, or deposition. Under the Dec 1, 2026 amendment, oath/proceeding is removed—any inconsistent statement is substantive if declarant testifies and is subject to cross-examination (recording not required).
Sector IV (Systems 28–36): Character (FRE 608) & Convictions (FRE 609)
FRE 608: Reputation/opinion of untruthfulness allowed; truthful character allowed only after character for truthfulness is attacked. Rule 608(b) allows cross-examination (with good-faith basis) on specific acts of dishonesty (fraud, falsifying forms), but strictly bars extrinsic evidence (even if witness denies it). Testifying does not waive 5th Amendment privilege for credibility-only matters.
FRE 609 Four Balancing Tiers:
• 609(a)(2) Dishonest Act / False Statement: Mandatory admission (no 403 discretion) if elements required proving/admitting deceit.
• 609(a)(1)(A) Felony (Non-Defendant / Civil Witness): Admitted unless Rule 403 dangers substantially outweigh probative value.
• 609(a)(1)(B) Felony (Testifying Criminal Defendant): Admitted only if probative value outweighs prejudice to defendant (ties go to exclusion).
• 609(b) Over 10 Years (since conviction or release, whichever is later): Probative value must substantially outweigh prejudice (reverse 403) + written notice.
Sector V (Systems 37–44): Religion, Rehabilitation & Lay Opinion
FRE 610: Religious beliefs/opinions strictly barred to attack or support credibility (though concrete organizational affiliation showing bias remains distinct).
Rehabilitation & FRE 801(d)(1)(B): Rehabilitation must match the attack (bias attack does not automatically open the door to Rule 608(a) truthful character reputation unless character was attacked). Prior consistent statements are substantive + rehabilitative if declarant testifies/subject to cross and either (i) rebuts recent fabrication/improper motive and predates the motive/bribe, or (ii) rehabilitates after another attack (e.g., faulty memory or contextual inconsistency).
FRE 701 Lay Opinion: Must be (a) rationally based on witness's perception, (b) helpful, and (c) not based on scientific, technical, or specialized knowledge under Rule 702.
Sector VI (Systems 45–52): Experts (FRE 702–706) & Flagship Boss
FRE 702 (2023 Amendment) & Daubert/Kumho: Proponent must prove to the judge more likely than not (Rule 104(a)) qualification, helpfulness (fit), sufficient facts/data, reliable principles/methods, and reliable application (702(d), barring unsupported claims of 100% certainty).
FRE 703 Reverse-403 Disclosure & Confrontation: Experts may rely on inadmissible data if reasonably relied upon in the field, but the proponent may disclose it to the jury only if probative value in evaluating the opinion substantially outweighs prejudicial effect. In criminal cases, conveying an absent analyst's testimonial statements for their truth violates Confrontation.
FRE 704–706: Rule 704(b) bars any expert in a criminal case from opining on whether the defendant had or lacked a mental state constituting an element of the crime or defense (even qualified with "probably").